Skip to content
  • Ships in 1–3 business days · Free 30-day returns
  • LIFETIME MENDING ON EVERY ITEM
Locate a Retailer

Cart

Your cart is empty

Nantucket Rollneck Sweater

Regular price$139.00

Fit

Relaxed boxy fit. Size down if needed.

Sizing Guide
Size:
Whalerknits Unisex Size Chart

Our sweaters are designed with a relaxed, boxy fit that works across body types. Use chest measurement as your primary guide. Our sweaters run generous — if you’re between sizes, size down.

Size

Chest (in)

Sleeve (in)

Waist (in)

Best Fit Description

Women's Size Guide

XXS

31–33

31–32

~25.5

Very slim / petite frame

00

XS

33–35

32–32.5

26.5-27.5

Slim build / fitted look

0-2

S

36–38

33–33.5

28.5-29.5

Standard small / slightly relaxed

4-6

M

39–41

34–34.5

30.5-31.5

Classic relaxed fit

8-10

L

42–45

35–35.5

33-34.5

Roomy / fuller fit

12-14

XL

46–49

36–36.5

36.5-38

Oversized on most

16-18

XXL

50–53

37–37.5

39.5-41.5

Very relaxed / extended sizing

20

XXXL

54–57

38–38.5

43-44.5

Maximum room / oversized

22+


FIT NOTES 

  • Designed with a traditional, boxy silhouette

  • Not tapered at the waist

  • Works well across a wide range of body shapes

  • Larger sizes accommodate broader shoulders without feeling tight

  • Smaller sizes are slightly scaled for shorter torsos

 

Size

Color:Natural / Nantucket Red

Shipping

Please allow 1-3 business days for our team to prepare your order for shipment.

Shipping policy

30-Day Returns & Exchanges

Returns must be initiated within 30 days of receiving your order.

Items must be new, unworn, and unwashed with all original tags attached.

Return policy

Free Standard Shipping and Free Returns on all orders within the United States.

KNIT IN FALL RIVER, MASS. SINCE 1975
✓ Knit on our own circular knitting machines at 502 Bedford Street
✓ Cut by hand · merrowed on Merrow Machines we build ourselves
✓ Made in USA — start to finish under one roof
✓ Guaranteed for life — we mend what we make
What that means

Designed, knit, cut, and sewn in Fall River, Massachusetts, at Fall River Knitting Mill. If it ever wears through, our Lifetime Mending policy covers it: send it back and the same workshop that knit it will mend it. Repair policy →


Whalerknits Sweaters XXS / Natural & Red / 100 % Cotton Nantucket Rollneck Sweater #Color_Natural / Nantucket Red
Nantucket Rollneck Sweater Regular price$139.00

A premium 100% cotton rollneck sweater praised for outstanding quality, soft fabric, and comfortable fit. Customers said it's "well-made" with "perfect weight." However, sizing runs large with some noting it's "too broad at shoulders" and "boxy." Color accuracy issues reported, particularly with red/dusty rose shades not matching photos. Highly valued for USA manufacturing.

Sweater (positive)Quality (positive)Weight (positive)Fabric (positive)Fit (neutral)
  • 5 stars: 35 (74%)
  • 4 stars: 6 (13%)
  • 3 stars: 2 (4%)
  • 2 stars: 3 (6%)
  • 1 star: 1 (2%)
F
Fredrick Tucker (Duncan, US)
L / Nantucket Red / Natural
The Stripes Aren’t Red!

The photo used to promote this sweater show a Christmas red, but the actual color used in the sweater shipped to me is a dusty rose shade. False representation!! The sweater is very lightweight. You’ll have to layer when wearing it.

J
Jacob

Exactly as described, fantastic weave

n
nick

Outstanding

j
j.o.

Love. Perfect & exactly what i was looking for.

D
David

Medium is unfortunately too broad at the shoulders, boxy rectangle in shape. Great color, material and interesting collar, also a bit too large.

C
Christopher Ciri (Boston, US)
Well built, great fit

I enjoy my first order so much, I quickly ordered a 2nd. Great quality item, well built and fit is true.

s
sam vander wielen (East Setauket, US)
Beautiful, soft sweater

This sweater is so beautiful- even better in person! I didn’t expect it to be so soft. I bought a size M for my husband (about 6 ft, 175lb) and it fits perfectly.

C
Cliff

Amazing quality and a large fits like a large.

N
Nicole Christ (Damariscotta, US)
Love this sweater!

My husband just received this as a birthday gift, it fits great. Its stylish, looks neat and is cotton so not too hot for him! Will recommend and purchase again in other colors!

s
stephen vasconcellos (Millsboro, US)
XL / Sky / Natural
Amazing sweater

Quality knit great colorways I’m sure
My wife will love it

M
Marianne Sutton (Bradenton, US)
Fantastic sweater

Great service excellent quality sweaters. They run large I’m a women’s small and the unisex XS is large on me but I haven’t washed it yet.

R
Robert Fisher (Richmond, US)
L / Natural / Seafoam

Beautiful fit, perfect weight.

M
Michelle (Los Angeles, US)
S / Seafoam / Natural
Nice sweater

Very pretty sweater. Unfortunately, it runs a bit larger than I would have thought given the size chart(s). Wish I had ordered an XS or an XXS instead of an S.

D
Dade Pepin (Taylor, US)
Great item

The sweater is heavy weight, has a good feel to the fabric weave and is very comfortable to wear. I would recommend this particular item and the company for an outstanding USA made product. I will definitely order more items in the future.

F
Frank S (Huntersville, US)
Love my sweaters

I first purchased the boatneck sweater and liked it so much I purchased the rollneck sweater. Fantastic quality and being 100% cotton very comfortable and easy to wash in washer/dryer. You will not be disappointed!

S
Stephanie Schwartz (Norwalk, US)
L / Natural / Sky
great sweater

so happy with my purchase

C
CappsJR (Riverside, US)
L / Sky / Natural
Perfect Weight & Comfy!

I was pleasantly surprised when I received the sweater, that the fabric was a perfect weight (med weight). I love the sleeves and the bottom of the sweater and the rollneck is not bulky!

R
Ralph Woodcock (Raleigh, US)

Ordered my first...loved it- so ordered another----I did not realize that with my first i had a discount card.... ; (

D
Danny Lewis (New York, US)
XL / Natural / Nantucket Red
Love it!

Great sweater, feels cozy and fits perfectly.

J
Joshua Levenson (Pittsburgh, US)
S / Natural / Sky

Sleeves too Broad, size is off.

R
Ronald Gage (Washington, US)
M / Sky / Natural
Too big on the bottom of sweater

I returned the sweeter. Although the quality and color was exactly what I was hoping, the cut is for a person with a much thicker waist area. It is too wide around the bottom of the sweater. Needs a tighter knit to fit me.

M
Mark Andrew Bradley (Towson, US)
S / Sky / Natural

Nantucket Rollneck Sweater

M
Mary Round (New York, US)

I love my sweater!!!

n
neil handelman (San Rafael, US)
M / Natural / Seafoam
Great sweater!

The Nantucket roll neck sweater is outstanding! Fits perfectly, great look at a reasonable price. I’m gonna buy another one.

L
Liz Waller (South Royalton, US)
S / Natural / Nantucket Red
Fabulous!

Purchased the Nantucket rollback sweater and couldn’t be more pleased! It’s not every day that one finds just the perfect fit, comfort, quality AND made one state away! Happy to support this company and plan to purchase more.

J
John Marshall (Seattle, US)
XL / Sky / Natural
Disappointment Prompts Return

There were two immediate problems with the Nantucket Rollneck Sweater when it arrived.
One was the color. In the online version, the sweater was medium blue with gray-ish stripes. What I received was light, almost baby blue with conventional white stripes. What looked intriguing in the online version turned out to be bland an ordinary in the sweater itself.
The other problem was size. I ordered XL since I tend to be a bit stout in physique and prefer that size. This sweater's XL proved to be humongous, with the top of the sleeves hitting me at mid-bicep.
So these two problems, combined, led me to return the sweater for refund (which was well-handled by customer service, I should add).
In sum, the color of the sweater should be the same online and in-person. Plus, there should have been an online advisory that the sweater runs way large.
John M.
Bainbridge Island, WA

D
David

Every sweater i have purchased from Whalerknits has been perfect.

R
Richard Bolton (Brewster, US)
NANTUCKET ROLLNECK

A beautiful quality classic. My customers love them.

R
Ross Caliendo (Los Angeles, US)
L / Natural / Nantucket Red

You can tell these were made w love

K
Kerry Whittaker (Somerville, US)
M / Natural / Nantucket Red

Nantucket Rollneck Sweater

Wear coastal new england - made in fall river

designed for new englanders - built for everybody

guaranteed. for life.